Child Care Centers Face Challenges in Finding Alternatives to Expulsion

An article from California highlights the challenges that child care centers face when it comes to handling difficult or unruly children. Well-intentioned laws prohibiting expulsion have become just another unfunded mandate. While the laws focus on the negative consequences of expulsion on unruly children, child care centers in California and other stares are discovering that being forced to keep the children in their programs has different and equally negative effects on both teachers and the remaining students.

One of the main obstacles in addressing expulsion is the lack of guidance and support for child care centers. Laws prohibiting expulsion simply create unfunded mandates, leaving administrators without the necessary resources to effectively manage challenging behaviors. This burden limits their ability to provide appropriate care for all children.

Legislators generally assume that child care centers have multiple alternative options for dealing with disruptive behavior. However, they fail to consider whether these options are readily available or affordable for centers to implement. For example, everyone agrees that children with behavioral disorders can benefit from counseling rather than expulsion, but there simply are not enough mental health services available for children. Mandating counseling does not help when there are no counselors available.

Furthermore, while current studies focus on the impact of expulsion on the children who are expelled, little attention has been given to the impact of unruly schoolmates on those who are trying to learn. Disruptive behaviors can create a hostile learning environment, affecting the well-being of both students and teachers. It is crucial to recognize the potential harm caused by allowing ongoing disruptive behavior to persist in classrooms. As one child care director explained in the article, “It’s so easy to say here’s this list of solutions, when you don’t have time and energy to get to them because you’re putting out fires every day.”

In order to address these challenges, it is important for policymakers and stakeholders to work together to find viable solutions. Unfunded mandates from legislators and bureaucrats don’t actually solve any problems. The rules make make policymakers feel good, but without funding and actual resources, they don’t make children any safer.

Subscribe to Taylor English Insights by topic here.