Incompetent Investigations Create Yet More Barriers to Recruiting Good Foster Parents

A recent story from Washington state outlines another barrier to recruiting good foster parents, specifically jumping to conclusions about allegations of mistreatment. A foster child accused a foster parent of physical abuse, and the state's investigation was less than adequate. Eventually, the courts vindicated the foster parent, but not until after she had spent tens of thousands of dollars clearing her name.

CPS investigations of abuse or neglect allegations are crucial processes that demand careful handling. While agencies should unquestionably hold foster parents accountable, it is equally important for them to conduct thorough and unbiased investigations. Caseworkers should be well-trained and follow protocols that ensure a comprehensive gathering of facts before reaching a conclusion. Above all, agencies should meet the same standards of professionalism that they expect from foster parents.

We also should consider policies that support foster parents during the investigation or appeals process. The financial burden of defending oneself against false allegations can be overwhelming. By providing assistance with legal fees or offering temporary financial support through a neutral third agency such as Legal Aid, states could alleviate some of the stress and anxiety that foster parents experience.

We need to hold foster parents accountable for their care of a vulnerable population. At the same time, we have to recognize that the fear of having their lives upended by false allegations may deter potential foster parents from stepping forward. We need to find ways to balance those two needs if we are to have a viable foster care system.