This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
Insights Insights
| less than a minute read

Adverse Effects of FTC's Proposed Ban on Noncompete Agreements

The FTC's controversial proposal to ban all forms of noncompete agreements in employment agreements will not only meet with strong criticism, but it may also have serious adverse economic effects.  According to the former Secretary of Labor, the rule would preempt laws in 47 states that currently allow some form of noncompete agreements. More importantly, the FTC's own evaluation of the potential effects of the ban include discouraging worker job training programs and at best delivering an increase of less than 3% in hourly workers wages while freeing up CEOs and other top executives to receive perhaps more than 9% compensation increases. Further, the ban would endanger capital investment by increasing the risk that trade secrets, expertise and competitive power would more readily move from company to company.

Did Congress ever intend for the FTC to regulate employment or to propose new laws (as opposed to enforcing a specific set of laws passed by Congress that regulate competition)?  There is no support for such an intent in the legislative history, past FTC practice or Supreme Court case law.  

The Federal Trade Commission’s ban on noncompete agreements may be the most audacious federal rule ever proposed. If finalized, it would outlaw terms in 30 million contracts and pre-empt laws in virtually every state. It would also, by the FTC’s own account, reduce capital investment, worker training and possibly job growth, while increasing the wage gap. The commission says the rule would deliver a meager 2.3% wage increase for hourly workers, versus a 9.4% increase for CEOs. The good news is that the proposal is unlikely to become law. The FTC seeks a “categorical ban” on postemployment noncompete agreements, with a sole exception for agreements in connection with the sale of a business. Companies would have 180 days to rescind their existing agreements.